18 March 2005

Voucher supporters want the choice of taking my tax dollars without offering me the choice of not contributing to their program

That's not choice, it's robbery. E.J. Montini is on the mark here, writing on why should proponents of school vouchers, a terrible idea, be granted special status to choose how tax money is spent. For example, I opposed the illegal, immoral invasion of the sovereign nation Iraq which threatened the United States not, but I'm not permitted to "choose" to get my tax money to spend on helping children suffering under poverty.
The income tax we all pay goes into one big pool. The politicians we elect then use our cash to pay for government services and programs like roads, prisons, health care, education and so on.

If I do not particularly like Arizona's transportation system, the law does not give me the right to receive a "voucher" that I could use to repair roads in my neighborhood or put a stoplight at the end of my driveway.

Likewise, I don't get to say that I want my personal tax dollars earmarked only for programs that help poor kids.

That's not how it works. You may be happy to pay the salary of the governor but not so happy about contributing income to certain legislators. But you don't have a "choice" in the matter.

Montini scored another point on this issue, earlier in the week, illustrating the blatant Republican hypocrisy on this issue

That would be as crazy as a bunch of elected officials saying that they would like to spend millions of taxpayer dollars on vouchers to send children to private schools, which are not required to administer the Arizona AIMS test, but upon which our elected officials have spent millions of taxpayer dollars. And yet, when the secret parlance of Arizona lawmakers was translated into English, that's exactly what the proposals said.

It is indeed crazy, but not entirely unexpected from Republican politicians who have the heartless desire of securing education for only the rich. Because that's the bottom line on vouchers — it's a siphon of money from public schools into the pockets of the affluent and gives a big "screw you" to children left in the public school system.


Glad to see another Arizona blogger against vouchers. Parents want strong, reliable public schools. They do not want another no-strings-attached tax cut for the rich.
Nice site, (http://www.shutupandteach.org), though the formatting is askew (i.e., on the "5 Good Reads" pages, the notebook hole pic margin intrudes on the text, making it difficult to read. Also, I loathe the use of frames…
Thanks, Naum. On the Frosty Troy page that was hard to read. Was your window maximized? I thought I had the table borders set to have enough margin. If the viewing window is narrow I know that the image and text overlap.

I had to go to frames to help with load times. Most of the people that come to my site need a menu that doesn't collapse or disappear.

Thanks again for visiting and for the comments.
No, actually using widescreen Mac Powerbook (or plugged into widescreen flat panel) and browser is Firefox or Safari.

The frames, I realize is a personal preference, but it is a hinderance to any competent browser user, as it becomes annoying (takes away power of user that should control his/her own windows + it takes up a bit of screen space).

Add Comment

This item is closed, it's not possible to add new comments to it or to vote on it